📣 Leslie Hardin, CHRO @ KC CARE Health Center:
I think the short answer is "it depends." Typically, there is a reason why someone left the organization. Depending on the organization, if there was a lot of change or growth – it may be appropriate to bring someone back under a different culture. If the person left for a more complex job and several years later wants to come back, then I think that's appropriate. Typically, if someone is disgruntled and/or leaves for reasons that haven't changed then I would say no.
📣 Melissa Stough, HR Coordinator @ Project Genesis:
I think both should be on a case-by-case basis with different considerations for both cases.
For rehiring employees, how they left and why they left should be taken into account. An employee may have left on very good terms (may not have even wanted to leave but had to for reasons unrelated to the company) and shouldn't be barred from rejoining an organization they liked because they chose to leave. My organization has specific policies on how to internally designate if people are eligible for rehire, but even then, we make exceptions if the reason was because they gave a shorter notice that we require or if significant time has passed. Depending on how long it has been since they worked for us, they have to go through the entire hiring process again or we just do an updated background check.
For hiring relatives, who the employee is matters. Individual contributors, so long as they are not working in situations where one could cover up for the other, shouldn't be an issue. If it's management, I think that's where things get tricky no matter what the position the relative applied for. Again, they would still have to go through the same hiring process as everyone else, but it shouldn't be an out-right ban.
📣 Sharon Hahne, HR Manager @ UW Madison Athletics:
I believe in keeping an open mind when it comes to rehiring individuals who have previously left, as long as they are qualified and left in good standing. People’s circumstances change, and their experiences elsewhere can bring valuable perspectives and skills back to the organization. I say, don’t hate the hustle – if they’re the best fit for the role, why not welcome them back?
As for hiring individuals related to current employees, I support it as long as the hiring process remains fair and transparent. If they’re qualified and meet the requirements for the position, family connections shouldn’t exclude them from consideration, provided that potential conflicts of interest are appropriately managed.
Safe Space members can join this discussion here. Not a member yet? Apply to join here.