| ||||||||
| ||||||||
| | ||||||||
Hiiiiii it’s Kiah, your friendly neighborhood bank reporter. I was unfortunately caught up in the national ground stop on Friday trying to have a lil bleisure weekend in Washington ahead of the American Fintech Council’s working groups on Monday and the Policy Summit on Tuesday (If you're reading this on Tuesday and attending, make sure to say hi!). Just wanted to say that while I absolutely wish it hadn't happened the way it did, I am grateful the planes landed safely and everyone erred on the side of caution. IF IF IF you are ever in an extended delay/ground stop situation and you’re not a carry-on girlie (🙋🏻♀️), here are some tips: use an AirTag or tracker in your luggage; take a photo of your luggage; if you used a travel credit card to book the ticket, download and familiarize yourself with the guide to benefits (great use of LLMs!); save screenshots of the delay, your ticket and any potentially eligible expenses; and reach out to hotels and restaurants to alert them about changes in your travel plans. Travel can be stressful, overwhelming and confusing even if it runs smoothly, and you may not need to stress about the additional expenses if your travel card offers protections. Speaking of travel credit cards… read on! 👀 Was this email forwarded to you? Sponsored by ElevenLabs Build, buy or both? That’s the first big decision when it comes to AI agents. What Hath Durbin WroughtOne of my very first introductions to financial journalism was early fallout from the Durbin amendment. I joined SNL Financial as a banks and thrifts reporter in October 2011 (having only recently learned what a thrift was). I was excited to be covering such an important industry. Just a few years earlier, I had watched regulators and lawmakers bail out these companies in the middle of the worst recession since the Great Depression, which the public believed they had helped create. Now everyone hated them! This is exactly the industry a baby financial journalist would want to cover. The big story that fall was that Bank of America Corp. planned to charge debit card customers $5 a month. People were livid. Bank of America had received $45 billion in bailout funds, which it had repaid only two years before. And now it was nickel-and-diming its customers, who had maybe experienced layoffs or a foreclosure?! Of course, Bank of America wasn’t the only bank that planned some fee — contemporaneous reports indicate that Wells Fargo & Co., JPMorgan Chase & Co., SunTrust Banks and Regions Financial Corp. were all testing or charging some type of debit card fee. But Bank of America became the whipping boy for politicians and an angry American public. Backlash was so intense that all of them had dropped these fees by early November. The driver behind this charge, I learned, was a price cap that had recently gone into effect and shrank the debit card interchange fees banks could collect. The cap was included as part of the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act, and is known as the Durbin amendment. This was an exciting way to start my career as a bank reporter! In the years since its passage, this amendment has reshaped the banking industry, and it has taught me many lessons. The first lesson is perhaps the most important one to remember: None of this is free, and the money to fund it comes from somewhere. The deposit account, debit card and online account services all cost the bank, to say nothing of the branches and ATMs I use, the deposit insurance and the account security I enjoy. So do the card networks that make debit cards accepted almost everywhere and settle transactions quickly and with finality. Durbin changed how many of those items were paid for. Changing the InterchangeSection 1075, which directed the Federal Reserve to cap debit interchange fees, was added on the Senate floor by Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., in May 2010 and passed 64-33. There were no committee hearings held specifically on this amendment, which would take his name, before the bill was signed into law in July. At the time, Durbin said, “Wall Street reform is really about two things: holding the big banks accountable for how they operate and empowering consumers to make good financial choices. Passage of this amendment is a win for the public on both fronts.” The statement added that lowering these interchange fees would “allow merchants to offer discounts to their customers and restore common sense and fairness to this broken system.” It said that in 2008, the card networks charged an estimated $48 billion in interchange fees, and 80% of that went to 10 large banks. To fix that dynamic, the amendment required that the interchange fees merchants pay to debit card issuers be "reasonable and proportional" to the issuer's cost of the transaction. It told the Fed to consider the incremental cost of authorizing, clearing and settling a transaction, but exclude other costs that aren't specific to a particular transaction. It allowed for a fraud-prevention adjustment. It also required that debit cards work on at least two unaffiliated networks, with merchants choosing which one to route each purchase over. It applied only to debit card issuers with $10 billion or more in assets. In June 2011, the Fed announced the interchange cap: 21 cents plus 5 basis points of the transaction value. Adding 1 cent for issuers that meet fraud-prevention standards brought the interchange fee on debit cards to “approximately 24 cents for the average debit card transaction, which is valued at $38,” the Fed’s release said. This newsletter is not about how the Fed set the rate, which is actively being litigated and will be the focus of a future newsletter. Instead, we’re going to look back at the impact of this amendment and how it shaped the financial services industry into what it is today. Filling the Hole Durbin DugSmall changes add up when you’re a big bank. After the Durbin amendment went into effect for large banks, the average “swipe fee” for covered transactions dropped from about 60 cents per transaction to approximately 20 cents, wrote Jason Mikula, the publisher of Fintech Business Weekly and author of a book on banking as a service. In 2011, Bank of America estimated the reduction in debit interchange would reduce revenue by $2 billion a year. Big banks killed their debit card rewards programs, which had been funded with interchange revenue. They then slowly reintroduced a fee structure for select accounts. By 2012, Bank of America was piloting programs in three states to assess monthly charges on certain accounts, with ways for customers to avoid the payments by “maintaining minimum balances, using a credit card or taking a mortgage with Bank of America,” the WSJ wrote. They also leaned on fees for nonsufficient funds, returned checks and overdrafts, which tend to be incurred by lower-income customers and made accessing financial services more expensive for them, according to Jason's book. Estimates vary on how much of the lost interchange revenue banks clawed back through other fees, largely in part due to the time periods measured and banks’ responses. A 2014 paper from the Federal Reserve Board calculated it was roughly 30%; an October 2025 paper in the Journal of Financial Economics estimated it was 14.3%. Another way to make up the lost debit interchange was to get consumers to shift their spending to credit cards, whose interchange rates weren’t subject to the cap and could be substantially higher. Of course, credit cards carry other appealing characteristics for banks, including interest income on revolving balances, but Durbin tilted the scales further. Post-Durbin and post-Great Recession, there was a credit card reward renaissance, according to American Banker in 2017. Capital One Financial Corp. launched the Quicksilver card in 2013, with Citigroup debuting its Double Cash card a year later. In 2016, Chase launched the Sapphire Reserve. U.S. credit card transactions grew slightly faster than the number of debit card transactions from 2012-15, which was “a huge turnaround” in activity over the previous decade, according to American Banker. Another indicator is that the big six card issuers issued $22.6 billion in rewards to customers in 2016, compared with $12.2 billion in 2011, the article said, citing a Nomura Instinet report. A New Industry Is BornThe Durbin amendment also changed the math for banks with less than $10 billion in assets. After it went into effect, a few smaller banks were able to capitalize on this pricing gap and grow revenue by partnering with companies that wanted to issue prepaid cards. Eventually, this became the blueprint for what became banking as a service, or BaaS. “By partnering with smaller banks, fintechs could bypass licensing logistics and benefit from the higher interchange, creating fertile ground for fintech growth,” wrote Eric Glyman, cofounder and CEO of spend management platform Ramp, in a piece authored with two of the company's investors in 2022. “The partner bank model was born: small banks lend out their charters to powerful fintech players. This allows fintech companies to offer financial products legally while also driving deposit and revenue growth for the partner banks.” In 2022, the average interchange fee per transaction for exempt banks was 52 cents, compared with just 23 cents on average for non-exempt banks, Jason wrote. That pricing disparity continues to influence the space today, given that the vast majority of BaaS banks are under $10 billion. “That small-entity exemption has allowed those banks to flourish in the space,” said Ian Moloney, chief policy officer for the American Fintech Council. “For the sub-$10 billion banks, it was a great opportunity to make the debit product profitable a little more easily and to leverage the innovators on the fintech side to do so.” Fortunately for consumers, these banks and fintechs were all very careful and compliant and nothing bad has happened since then. Kidding! [This newsletter really can’t get into all the BaaS drama, but if you want to contemplate the complexity of BaaS, can I suggest you buy Jason’s book?] Ian also credited Durbin with pushing innovation toward payment methods that bypass cards altogether, such as pay-by-bank and stablecoins. “It's interesting to see that dynamic play out and how it's created a lot of innovation, but I don't think that was necessarily the original intent of the Durbin cap,” he said. “It was a cost-structure mechanism. That's always interesting from an economic standpoint, to see how things develop.” Spawning an entire subset of financial services companies may be the Durbin amendment's biggest legacy, and its least foreseen. This storyline continues evolving today, as some fintechs that partnered with banks to provide these financial products are becoming banks themselves. The Merchant Fees Are Too Damn HighThe stated purpose of the Durbin amendment — the reason for all this upheaval — was to lower the interchange charges that merchants would pay, which would allow them to lower prices for consumers. But the bill didn’t require merchants to pass along savings to customers, and they didn’t seem to. A 2015 survey from the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond found that more than three-quarters of merchants did not change prices post-regulation, with less than 2% reducing prices. About 20% of merchants increased prices. This came even as the cost of debit card acceptance declined by more than $7 billion annually after the cap went into effect, according to a 2013 study looking at the impact of the interchange cap on consumer welfare. But the same study estimated consumers would lose $22 billion to $25 billion over time through higher bank fees and reduced services, and that merchants weren't passing along enough savings to make up the difference. “Consumers got the short end of the stick,” the researchers wrote. “Merchant[s] are not giving enough of their gains back to consumers to compensate for the higher fees and reduced services that consumers are getting from banks as a result of the interchange price caps, nor, as we have shown, are merchants expected to do so.” There’s also an argument to be made that Durbin ultimately raised transaction costs for merchants over the long run. In his book, Jason pointed out that merchants with smaller average transactions may have seen their payment processing costs go up. Before Durbin, card networks sometimes offered preferential interchange pricing incentives to these merchants, which they eliminated after the amendment. But consumers may have also been enticed to use their new, lucrative credit cards for more of their daily spending, according to the same October 2025 study. “The accelerated adoption of credit cards with higher interchange fees likely diminished—if not eliminated—merchants’ savings.” A Settled Issue?Over the last 15 years, the incentives created by, and responses to, the Durbin amendment turned it into the banking industry’s own natural experiment in how unintended consequences can overshadow, or even negate, intended ones. Today, the big banks offer reward credit cards and debit accounts with strings attached. Today, consumers pay both their merchants and banks for the privilege of using a card. Today, Chime is buying its longtime bank partner with money made largely from debit interchange swipes, and it plans to keep the bank under $10 billion. Today, there is a near-permanent class of banks whose entire business model is predicated on never growing above $10 billion so they can keep a debit interchange fee that is more than double what their larger peers collect. Durbin today is an industry quirk. A thing we all live with. It was also, importantly, a largely settled issue. The banks didn’t like it, but once the Federal Reserve established the price, the banking industry mostly moved forward. The retail industry? Not so much. We’ll get into that in a future newsletter. Sponsored by Stitch Stitch replaces banks’ fragmented legacy systems with one modern operating system and built-in AI, all under the bank's own controls. FROM THE VAULT What’s on my mind and filling my time: 🏉 Haunted by: this Bloomberg News analysis of Massachusetts sports bettors’ spending in the three years since the state legalized online betting, to better understand their spending behaviors and calculate the losses of the heaviest ones. 🎼 Mood music: Kaitlyn Raitz, a Nashville-based composer and cellist, recently released “silent suites,” which are holiday compositions for quiet moments, and it’s just what I crave for evening reading and wind-down time. (Her debut “Me, Myself, Myself, and I” is an always-listen.) 🎙️ On Bank Nerd Corner: Alex and I discuss the latest banking and AI developments, the implications of the midterms and the first big bank case in the post-Loper Bright world. 🛫 Catch me at: Piper Sandler’s Balance Sheet Strategy Seminar on Dec. 7 in New York. 🎤 Bonus Podcast Rec: What could the next phase in AI maturity look like? In the latest episode of Agent of Record, produced in partnership with Parlay Finance, Alex McLeod and I discuss the platformification of agentic AI with Madeline Fredin, senior vice president of growth and AI transformation at Alloy Labs. Agents are starting to span systems, which is why Madeline believes bankers need an "agentic OS" layer to manage, govern and audit these agents. Listen now to learn more!* *This rec is brought to you by one of our fantastic brand partners. In addition to the first big story in banking I covered as a baby bank reporter, I gladly participated in the Great Reward Credit Card Renaissance that Durbin contributed to. Today, I have 16 credit cards and paid a little over in $3,000 in annual fees this year. By my (detailed) spreadsheet, I have redeemed $10,000 in benefits this year, including 9 one-way flights and 26 nights in hotels. Outside of sheer monetary value, these cards allowed me to participate in events that meant a lot to me, including a destination race with friends, two dear friends' weddings and my college newspaper's 125th anniversary. Thanks for reading! As always, feel free to reply to this email and let me know your thoughts (or Durbin memories). - Kiah | ||||||||
|
